This week, students received a P (pass), LP (low pass) or F (fail) followed by a few sentences from each of their teachers. Midterm comments, which are accessible to students and parents, are meant to give students preemptive feedback on their academic performance. Yet, despite the P/F nature of midterm comments, many students await them in intimidation, and can be confused by the variation between their teachers’ comments.
The often unfounded emotions we’ve observed over midterm comments have inspired us to share what we believe are the goals of comments, and suggest how these goals can best be fulfilled.
So, why midterm comments in the first place? After all, most of us have a reasonable sense of whether we’re passing or failing long before we receive our comments. And if we want to know how we can improve as students, why not simply use our beloved conference times to speak to our teachers in person?
We believe that the value in midterm comments lies not in the novelty of their information but in that they provide us clear documentation of our performance. Sometimes, they may merely give us reassurance. Other times, we can reference them back over the term, asking about important pieces in conferences and thinking about how they can improve the way we study. We should recognize that we need not stress over midterm comments; they can only benefit us.
But for teachers, perhaps a clearer, more consistent structure of midterm comments would ensure that students are able to equally benefit from comments. Indeed, while some students mention receiving clear one through six grades in their comments, others have shared that they’re provided only vaguely positive feedback. While some students receive a few sentences of critique and areas to improve, others are left wondering where they can best develop as a student.
A structure adapted across disciplines and built in collaboration with students and faculty could allow for more consistent feedback. The structure might include the most influential components of a student’s performance, such as their test scores, participation, and room for growth. Structure could also save time for teachers, so that they need not search for scattered pieces of a student’s performance and instead know exactly the components to include.
As we head into the second half of term, let’s remember that there are ample ways to improve, and midterm comments should help give us the agency and guidance to do so. Acts like showing up to conferences, meeting with our advisors, and self-reflecting on our class performance can personally empower us while showing us the value in engaging with our support systems. Midterm comments are only one step on this journey, but they should be done well and responded to even better.