This fall, many students opened their classroom syllabi to see an unannounced adjustment: the benchmark to achieve a six is now a 94 percent. Previously, the cutoff for a six ranged from 92 to 94 percent. Following an official recommendation from the Academic Council to make a six a 94 percent, several courses have adopted the higher cutoff.
Over the past years, grade inflation has been rising slowly. The 2018 State of the Academy (SOTA) reported that the average Winter Term GPA for a student at Andover was 5.18. Now, that number has surged to 5.4. When the 0-6 scale was initially adopted in 1968, the administration believed that the simpler structure would reduce Andover’s competitive academic culture. Yet now, nearly sixty years later, the significance behind each number on the scale has changed dramatically.
The recommended 94 percent presumably represents the administration’s effort to combat rising grade inflation. Campus adults have also pointed to improving grading consistency across sections of the same course. “Consistency” in this sense means that teachers have more well-defined and similar standards for what constitutes 5-level work or 6-level work.
While the school raised grade percentages to increase consistency, it fails to directly address the problem at hand: varying grading standards among teachers. Granted, no grading system is perfect. Teachers inherently have different expectations; nonetheless there are some flaws in the new 94-for-a-six recommendation. Not all teachers use the same initial grading scale. While some directly grade from zero to six, others grade on a 0-100 scale and convert to a 0-6 scale at the end of each term. Therefore, only courses using the 0-100 grading scale are affected by the 94 percent cutoff.
The school aimed to increase grade consistency by suggesting a standardized cutoff. At the same time, they presumably aimed to deflate grades by raising said cutoff. However, since the 94 percent is a recommendation rather than a requirement, confusion and anxiety falls unevenly on students depending on their course load. Perhaps it is a testament to the scrutiny around grading that an editorial even exists over a one percent adjustment. But it’s undeniable that students are feeling more stressed because of this change, no matter how numerically minor it is.